The Transparency Challenge


Are you hiding your best strategies ONLY for your highest paying clients?

Do you clearly see solutions for your lower paying clients… but hold back so you can keep them buying from you?

You may have been taught to teach the “what” but not the “how”. Or to deliver only part of what you could and to drum up a desire for what’s missing. I was taught that by some mentors, tried to believe it, but it never felt authentic. It felt deceptive and quite frankly, like an insecure person’s fear based version of how to run a business.

There’s a power dynamic in this thinking… the person with the sought after information suddenly becomes more important and the person seeking the information is relegated to a lower level.


Am I the only one who thinks this is insane?
I can hand you sheet music of Beethoven’s symphony, but that doesn’t mean you’ll play like a master. We have all the information in the world at our fingertips- it’s mastery that we need and that doesn’t happen by sharing a few trade secrets.



I got really in tune with this a few months back.
I created a mastermind program where a small, hand-selected group of soul-driven women could work on creating great offers. Offers that made us stretch and say “yikes!” and “holy crap, I can’t do this!” My invitation to this group clearly stated that it was a “studio” experience- that while I work on my big offers, I’d share exactly what was going on and for everyone else to do the same.

So I created this whopping big VIP package that would cost a small down payment on a home, and brought it to the group. I thought I’d invented the new gold standard in high end coaching packages. I felt luminous just thinking about it.

It got shredded. Totally absolutely unequivocally shredded. “Too complicated”, “Sounds like work- why would anyone pay for this?”, “It’s overwhelming”.

Here I thought it was brilliant, but it sucked.

And the beauty of all this? My clients LOVED watching me work my way into and out of a problem in a real world scenario. It helped them open up about what worked and didn’t work for them and also gave many permission to drop the veneer of perfection we’re “supposed” to show the world.

It’s like that scene from Gone With the Wind where all the ladies got to take a rest break and unlace their corsets for a bit. Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, breathing feels so nice!

So where can you be transparent?

  • Can you let someone know you’re making them an offer instead of dancing around until your big close?
  • Are you willing to Tweet that you’re NOT happy with a situation or does everything have to be perfect all the time?
  • Would you be open to sharing mistakes with your clients, mistakes you’re in the middle of or recently solved?
  • Will you raise your hand and freely admit that the “lifestyle” you’re peddling doesn’t reflect you at all  and that all your marketing is a lie? (OK, that’s a stretch, but one of these days it may happen!)

You don’t have to suddenly bare all to the world or go neurotic on this. We’re not asking for TMI (too much info) or bashing of others in the name of speaking the truth.

Simply  look at your business and your clients. Where can you infuse some reality, some authenticity, some transparency? What “trade secrets” are you willing to loosen up on? How can you use that to invite in a desire to learn mastery from you, not just info? And how can you be clear about this?

That’s what I’m doing in my business and it’s awesome. I’d much rather mentor towards mastery and watch the real results instead of safeguarding information.

I’d love your comments on this and where you’re willing to loosen the reins of control and to invite your people behind the veil of your expertise.


Share this resource!

Share on Digg!  Share on Delicious!  Share on StumbleUpon!  Share on Google Buzz!

About Nancy Marmolejo

I'm a soul-driven strategist who teaches entrepreneurs how to turn followers into fans and fans into clients using social media and heart based marketing. My approach integrates proven strategies and intuitive hits so each client finds her special way to stand out and sizzle in the spotlight.

  • http://www.john-edwards-blog.com/ Ed.

    Hi Nancy,I feel people want success that much, they screen there products, they wear the blinkers hoping people just buy and don`t find any chinks in the armour, afraid once they come to light it deflates their confidence in the future of sales taking off?I feel you touched on this with this post, fantastic content Nancy….Ed.

  • Dawn

    Yay!!! I'm soooo glad you did this post! I've been to so many high end expensive marketing events just to leave feeling like I'm going to have to hide things from clients to be successful. It's actually kept me from starting my biz…the passion I had for what I love actually faded in the awareness of running the biz! Now, I'm seeing through you and some other mentors that being transparent and teaching the how with the what is ok (Yay!!) and I love the "mastery" concept!
    Thanks Nancy!!

  • beverlyboston

    Nancy,The first thing that came to my mind when reading this was when you "get real" drop everything, show your panties so to speak, your vulnerability becomes your strength to have the inner confidence, certainty, and courage to be real best version of yourself.

  • http://www.empoweredsoul.com/ Andrea|Empowered Sou

    Love this, Nancy! I think transparency encourages people to recognize that we are all works in progress, that we're all dealing with some level of insecurity no matter how successful we become, and that we don't have to be anything other than who we are in order to create what we want.

  • http://www.amymiyamoto.com/ Amy Miyamoto

    Nancy – I love the lens of "mentor towards mastery" vs. safegaurding information. Such a key shift for me and I am guessing many others…"aaaaaahhhhhh!"Thank you my dear for starting this important conversation! ;) Amy

  • http://www.melaniekissell.com melaniekissell

    Hallelujah! Somebody needed to say this out loud and I'm so glad it was YOU.I believe the best approach to being transparent and genuinely authentic is to practice the art of "non-conformity". Move away from the S.O.S. (Same Old Stuff). There's too much bland "predictability" and greed in this industry, Nancy, and far too many self-proclaimed experts with less-than-stellar offerings.Before the release of a new product, service, or program, I would love to see more people ASK their target market what they would be willing to pay. Find out what their current budgets will hold. Make customers and clients feel important and show them that their input really does matter. Allow them to play a vital role in the decision-making process. I also feel that people would get a lot more subscribers and sales if they would stop filling their preview calls and teleseminars with sparse bits of semi-useful information (when they've promised something better than sliced bread!). There's really no tactful way to say this, Nancy. I can't speak for everyone else, but I don't appreciate getting my intelligence insulted or wasting my valuable time on fluff.Thanks for indulging me. :-) Transparency Counts!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    It feels good doesn't it? I'm sensing a big sigh of relief from many and also sensing some gurus getting a bit nervous that the bar is now raised. Thanks for sharing your input!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    You're so right Andrea! I remember when people got all over Kathie Lee Gifford all those years back. I couldn't quite figure out why she was such a target. Then someone said, "Well, she's always acting like she's got this perfect life, it's kinda making us all wanna puke."People can't relate to perfect. It's just not human.thanks for sharing your brilliance here!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    "Your vulnerability becomes your strength"… yes!!Beverly, I see you as a master of jujitsu, teaching others how to smartly use the forces around us to land gracefully and look great in our panties… so to speak. (Can't talk about your work without some choni references):-)

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Dawn, I'm so glad you are feeling inspired to raise the bar and deliver!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Ed, thank you for your ongoing comments here! You're always one of the first to chime in and you always have a great insight.

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    You bring up some great points, Melanie. Regarding the preview calls, it is supposed to be just a taste of something bigger coming up… but it needs to have some flavor otherwise who will come back for the full plate?

  • http://positivelywed.com/ Dina Eisenberg| Posi

    I love transparency; it makes life so much easier. I know people worry about 'what will happen if I say exactly what I want or that I'm not perfect'. I used to, but once I started being more transparent and direct my life got a lot happier.Seems to me the whole 'what not how' thing is really about fear. Fear that one's knowledge just isn't deep or solid enough to really give it all away; otherwise, there won't be any left to sell. Perhaps stinginess increases a sense of exclusivity for some, but, for me, it makes me wonder how soon the new material will end.So true about the sheet music. Nancy, you inspired me AGAIN! I'm gonna talk a little more about why transparency shouldn't be scary on my blog next week. You rock!Warmly, Dina

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Thanks Dina! Send me a tweet when you post that blog. @NancyMarmolejoI'd love to read it.

  • http://www.melaniekissell.com melaniekissell

    Bon Apetite!

  • cathybrennan

    Thanks, Nancy. I have always felt a disconnect with holding back key information, it is scarcity mentality. When you allow yourself to be transparent you allow yourself to shine and that enables others to shine. You are a great model for that in your business.

  • shawndriscoll

    Nancy,Spot on, as you often do! You've heard me rant about the whole 'paying for access' issue and what a disservice I think it is to everyone involved.When you create enough trust between you and your audience that you can safely be transparent they'll feel raised up, not let down. It's by being human and shining your light, Nancy, that I learn the most from you.I believe our job is to give clients a path of growth to follow, not to limit their access to us or to our so-called secrets. You set a great example of that!Thanks so much. Lead a life of difference,Shawn

  • Beth Earle

    I'll take the Transparency Challenge Nancy! I'm just starting my business as a life coach and want to share that everyone in the entire world has issues of some sort. I've been designing my life to be the one I truly want to live and so I've done work in every area of my life. There are still some things I'm working on, and so I have found my own coaches. Being open with others, willing to admit mistakes, and share "failures", which I consider to be lessons learned so one can achieve success, are important. Always give your best to all your clients and be yourself and I think your business and life will be more satisfying.

  • Anonymous

    Nancy,
    Great post! This is what hit home for me: "We have all the information in the world at our fingertips- it’s mastery that we need and that doesn’t happen by sharing a few trade secrets."
    Mastery indeed is what we need and I'm beginning to see how I help my clients achieve mastery. This is going to help in the Profitable Essence work I'm doing with you.

    Thanks,
    Marena

  • marenadrlik

    Nancy,Great post! This is what hit home for me: "We have all the information in the world at our fingertips- it’s mastery that we need and that doesn’t happen by sharing a few trade secrets."Mastery indeed is what we need and I'm beginning to see how I help my clients achieve mastery. And (some transparency here) how I was expecting to achieve mastery in marketing my business by buying everyone's programs, thinking more info would do the trick. This will really help in the Profitable Essence work I'm doing with you.Marena

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    I think you've called the Emperor Naked, Marena! What I love is how you see this as an asset to what you offer your clients!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Oh no, Beth… you mean life coaches don't have PERFECT lives? !!!??;-)

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Shawn we've been there done that bought the t-shirt, huh? You're a great example of offering the best quality. Path of Growth to follow -vs- having them pay us to hop over the closely guarded wall… that's it.

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Thanks Cathy, and what I see more and more is that the people who invest the most with me are the ones who truly want that ongoing mastery and mentoring… there's a chemistry there that's powerful and divine!

  • http://www.vanillasoul.co.nz/ Janine Lattimore

    Hi NancyI love the mentor towards mastery concept too. I have been tuning into the info of Andrea Conway over the past couple of months. I find it quite enlightened. She teaches and lives 'journey'. I sense that you've had a bit of a soul enlightenment lately too. The spirit of what you have been presenting seems to have changed a little. For the better I feel.I get so jaded with the stock standard "set yourself up as an expert, offer a free ebook, build your list and move people on to your high-end products". Not to say that these arn't good business techniques, but sometimes the personality, spirit and community gets lost.Sometimes I think its just about language. The concept of expert implies that you are the perfect font of knowledge – and nobody is. If you are not constantly learning and journeying then ironically you are not an 'expert'. Mentor implies more of a journey together with one just slightly ahead.I also like the concept that has come through some of the comments about honouring the intelligence of your customers. One of the things I try to do on my website and facebook profile is invite the contribution of my 'fans' because they have valuable information and ideas to contribute too. I think that some of this comes down to the level of confidence you have in yourself.

  • http://www.vanillasoul.co.nz/ Janine Lattimore

    Hi NancyI love the mentor towards mastery concept too. I have been tuning into the info of Andrea Conway over the past couple of months. I find it quite enlightened. She teaches and lives 'journey'. I sense that you've had a bit of a soul enlightenment lately too. The spirit of what you have been presenting seems to have changed a little. For the better I feel.I get so jaded with the stock standard "set yourself up as an expert, offer a free ebook, build your list and move people on to your high-end products". Not to say that these arn't good business techniques, but sometimes the personality, spirit and community gets lost.Sometimes I think its just about language. The concept of expert implies that you are the perfect font of knowledge – and nobody is. If you are not constantly learning and journeying then ironically you are not an 'expert'. Mentor implies more of a journey together with one just slightly ahead.I also like the concept that has come through some of the comments about honouring the intelligence of your customers. One of the things I try to do on my website and facebook profile is invite the contribution of my 'fans' because they have valuable information and ideas to contribute too. I think that some of this comes down to the level of confidence you have in yourself.

  • martha

    i think when you are honestly transparent, you have to use your wisdom and insight as to when. some crowds are tough and cruel and what you say makes no difference. Most people however, like you more when you do reveal the most you can. I know when I share my vunerabilities openly, I feel a sense of bonding with others.

  • Beth Earle

    Nancy,

    I just find out today that I should use the world challenges, not issues. ;)

  • http://VisionForSuccess.biz Ali R. Rodriguez

    Transparency sometimes goes hand in hand with vulnerability, which can be right down scary. So it is in conquering the fear of being naked in the public eye and sharing full out, that we fulfill our destiny of success in being of "value" while in the service of. You are right in keywording success with "Mastery".

  • http://gardenplum.com/ Wendy

    Wow Nancy I was unaware some coaches teach to hold back only to make their upcoming offers look different! That is "icky"! I love your honesty and authenticity. Being human in all of its' diversity will one day be OK in business. And on twitter. And in marketing. It is all about transparency. The playing field is becoming level. Emotional Intelligence will play a big role upcoming.

  • Veronica

    Hi Nancy,This remainds me of a marketing coaching conversation I heard given to a New Thought Minister. The woman told her not to give complete relief to people coming to a workshop, or a service, so that they will get into the paid stuff of her ministry. The way it works for me is that when something works once, next time another challenging situation presents itself I’ll know where to look for support.Still, I understand that it makes sense from a marketing perspective.I look forward to read your comment on that, Nancy. Thanks in advance,~Veronica

  • http://www.rightbrainplanner.com/ stargardener

    The first step into transparency is the most eye-bugging, clenched-jawed, heart-racing step we ever take! But after we realize we are not going to explode, the initial sheer terror quickly evaporates. BUT that first step *is* a doozy! ;-) During the past eight weeks, transparency proved to exactly what I needed in order to receive insightful feedback. I admitted to myself, my readers and my peer group that I needed to scrap my {black and white} business management service in order to pursue a colorful {collage} version of consulting exclusively with solopreneurs. The sky didn't fall and no one thought I had a screw loose. And it has been the most liberating experience to simply let go of what I know and take those first steps into a brand new direction! Learning as I go!

  • StephCalahan

    Bravo Nancy! I have paid for many of those courses you mention and have never understood a hold-back philosophy. Many new consultants in my industry ask me why I give away all of my tips. They think I'm nuts! I share with them that there are websites, books, etc. that people can get the information. Some people are fine with just having the info and they get it from me and are happy. I want to work with those clients that want MORE. Love your mastery concept because that is exactly what we do when we work directly with our clients.When I first started my blog a few years ago, I just shared tips and tricks. I switched shortly though. It just did not feel "real" to me. I'm a productivity and organization consultant for businesses and the first transparent post I ever wrote was about how perfectionism can hurt. In it I admitted to not being a "perfect" housekeeper–we don't live in a "Martha Stewart" home. I own it. Our home works for our lifestye.I share my life challenges and relate what I'm working on learning (like the work I'm most recently doing changing my life patterns and eating by working with my nutritionist) and how my readers can learn about working through their challenges. LOL just today on twitter I admitted that Girl Scout Thin Mint cookies were my complete downfall with my eating plan. I still don't share a lot of personal information (some stuff is just that — personal) but what I do share is complete. I'm up for your challenge. There is always opportunity to be more transparent and I'll be looking for those opportunities.Thank you for encouraging us to continue with "being real." I appreciate you and keep the posts coming.To your success!Stephanie

  • http://www.ubervu.com/conversations/vivavisibilityblog.com/the-transparency-challenge/ uberVU – social comments

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Facebook by Carolyn Ellis: Another gr8 post! RT @MichelePW: RT @NancyMarmolejo The Transparency Challenge http://bit.ly/cfWL0T...

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Stephanie, I'm here to encourage you on the challenge! Weaving in who you are as a person is certainly a big part of transparency, and also as you and I agree, mentoring people towards mastery through honest examples and admitted mistakes. thanks for the comment!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Whew! I can feel the relief just reading your comment. The heart racing feeling is a good indicator that we're on to something… nothing quite like walking through a fear to grow ourselves stronger. Congrats on your commitment to focusing on what you're brilliant at. The world is getting a gift from you simply from that bold brave action!!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Veronica, this is a really good example, thanks for posing the situation here. There are lots of ways to help people towards their breakthroughs. Maybe what the coach intended to say was to meet people at the level where they are and then to provide the next steps for them that they can invest in. Designing something with the intention of it not being enough and therefore they'll HAVE to sign up for number 2 is way different than offering a series of steps people can engage in as they develop.Does that make sense? I'd love to hear what other people have to say if anyone else wants to chime in.

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Thank you Wendy for your gutteral response… yes, the "ick" factor is running high these days! I think a lot of it is being able to share the imperfections as a way for all of us to learn.

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Thanks Ali! Vulnerability is way scary, I so agree with you! And there is wise vulnerability (like sharing that a certain strategy no longer works as well or that you have changed your philosophy on something you once held dear) and there is stupid vulnerability (sharing every sordid detail of your personal life or bashing others in the name of "truth"). As long as we focus on mastery, EVERYTHING is a lesson for us all.

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Tempering it with wisdom is key, Martha. Thanks for sharing that comment!

  • http://www.VivaVisibilityBlog.com NancyMarmolejo

    Thanks for such a thoughtful response Janine, and yes I've had a bit of a soul enlightenment! I made a conscious decision to let go of people and things that no longer served my mission, my values, and my business. In doing so I feel like a spell was broken- there were still parts of me (and I didn't even realize it) that were tied to old beliefs that were never really mine to begin with. As soon as that breaking free happened, my intuitive voice got stronger and stronger and is flooding me with ideas, insights, and so much more. I'm feeling very blessed by all that is coming to me right now.

  • http://VisionForSuccess.biz Ali R. Rodriguez

    Totally concur….that's the way the transparency cookie crumbles…